1. Global strategies
  2. Substituting technology for natural resources

Substituting technology for natural resources

  • Replacing natural capital with anthropogenic capital

Context

Natural capital and anthropogenic capital are treated as independents, but anthropogenic capital is dependent on, and draws from, the natural capital resource base for its maintenance and expansion. Technology can substitute for a decline in natural capital; or at least, that within fixed environmental constraints, new technology can facilitate an increase in productivity within those parameters. A similar view holds that a depreciation of natural capital can be compensated for by an increase in man-made (anthropogenic) capital. For example, material scarcity is no longer an issue when current technological developments substitute abundant supplies of carbon and silicon for less abundant materials such as copper and zinc.

There are two lines of thought that follow from this. One is a tolerance of natural capital depletion by ignoring ethical considerations and the intrinsic non-monetary value of nature and ecosystems irrespective of their worth to economic output. The second is that greater reliance on anthropogenic capital can reduce depreciation of natural capital (e.g. recyclable synthetic paper to replace paper derived from logging primary growth forests).

Claim

Limits to growth proponents argue that the elasticity of substitution is less than one, in some cases far less, leading to a decreasing marginal product of capital, ie as natural capital is depleted a proportionately greater amount of (anthropogenic) capital is required per unit output).

Counter-claim

Substituting technology for natural resources is a non-issue that distracts from real challenges. Humanity has always innovated, and the idea that we must replace natural resources with technology is misguided. Nature and technology can coexist harmoniously, enhancing our lives without the need for drastic substitutions. Focusing on this supposed problem diverts attention from pressing issues like climate change and social inequality, which require our urgent and collective action. Let's prioritize what truly matters!This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Broader

Value

Unnaturalness
Yet to rate

SDG

Sustainable Development Goal #7: Affordable and Clean EnergySustainable Development Goal #9: Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure

Metadata

Database
Global strategies
Type
(F) Exceptional strategies
Subject
  • Commerce » Finance
  • Geography » Nature
  • Resources » Resources
  • Technology » Technology
  • Content quality
    Presentable
     Presentable
    Language
    English
    1A4N
    J6397
    DOCID
    12063970
    D7NID
    204558
    Last update
    Mar 21, 2022