1. Global strategies
  2. Establishing joint sovereignty regimes

Establishing joint sovereignty regimes

  • Establishing joint dominion over a territory
  • Operating a territory under joint rulership

Context

A number of intractable geo-political situations illustrate the need for more flexible and innovative approaches to sovereignty. Classic examples are Jerusalem (and more broadly Palestine) and Northern Ireland, where religious and/or ethnic dimensions increase the difficulty of any negotiated solution.

Implementation

The most striking example was the Anglo-French Condominium of the New Hebrides, established in 1906, which acquired independence in 1980. The administration was structured into three parts: the French National Service, the British National Service and the Condominium (Joint) Departments. The UK and France were each responsible for their own citizens and for indigenous people who chose to be ressortissants of either power, although the indigenous were not permitted to claim either French or UK nationality. In practice this resulted, in the same territory, in two official languages, two police forces, and three public services. The island of St Maarten in the Caribbean is jointly governed by France and the Netherlands, although the island is geographically divided. Andorra is a co-principality established in 1278, currently under the suzerainty of the President of France and the Spanish Bishop of Urgel, although since 1993, these positions have become purely honorary.

Claim

Where more conventional efforts to conflict situations have failed over many years, there is a strong case for exploring formulas for joint sovereignty over a a common territory. Options might include choice of nationality, dual nationality, attribution of certain functions to one system of government and the remainder to another. Such formulas could extend to voting and taxation systems.

Counter-claim

Establishing joint sovereignty regimes is a trivial concern in the grand scheme of global issues. With pressing challenges like climate change, poverty, and health crises demanding urgent attention, focusing on joint sovereignty distracts from real solutions. The complexities of governance and territorial disputes can be resolved through existing diplomatic channels without convoluted joint arrangements. Prioritizing this topic only diverts resources and energy from addressing the critical problems that truly impact humanity's future.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Broader

Operating
Yet to rate
Establishing
Yet to rate

Facilitates

SDG

Sustainable Development Goal #16: Peace and Justice Strong Institutions

Metadata

Database
Global strategies
Type
(F) Exceptional strategies
Subject
  • Government » Nation state » Nation state
  • Government » Government
  • Content quality
    Yet to rate
     Yet to rate
    Language
    English
    1A4N
    J4899
    DOCID
    12048990
    D7NID
    200637
    Last update
    Nov 9, 2022