Stag hunting

Deer hunting

Nature

Stag hunting refers to a traditional form of hunting where a group of hunters, often on horseback, pursues a stag (male deer) using hounds. As a problem, stag hunting raises significant ethical and environmental concerns. Critics argue that it causes unnecessary suffering to animals, disrupts ecosystems, and promotes class divisions, as it is often associated with the elite. Additionally, the practice can lead to overhunting and population imbalances in deer species. Many regions have enacted bans or restrictions on stag hunting, reflecting growing public sentiment against such practices and the need for sustainable wildlife management.

Incidence

On average, a stag hunt lasts 3 hours and covers around 12 miles. When the stag is finally caught by the hounds, it is at the point of total exhaustion. Scientific analysis of blood samples taken from hunted stags reveals a litany of suffering. In the early stages of the chase, glycogen and blood sugar levels fall sharply. As the hunt progresses, fatty acids in the blood rise, indicating high physiological stress levels. Red pigment in blood plasma increases, caused by ruptured blood cells. In the later stages of the hunt, high levels of muscle enzymes appear in the blood, indicating life-threatening muscle damage.

Claim

The cruelty involved in hunting deer with hounds does not justify its ineffective role as a means of culling populations.

Despite its name, stag hunting is not confined to the male of the species. Hinds are hunted too, sometimes when they are pregnant or with a calf at heel. Stag or hind, the end is the same. A free wild animal is hunted to death.

In areas where deer need culling it is more efficient and more humane for them to be shot by a marksman.

Counter-claim

Deer in the wild are accustomed to being chased; it is not clear what extra stress, if any, they suffer as a result of being hunted. But probably the hunt's most important contribution to the welfare of the deer is the preservation of the moorland and woodland in which they live. Hunting plays a vital role in preserving the habitat on which the deer depend and in securing the goodwill and cooperation of landowners and farmers in managing deer numbers. Without hunting, such land could be ploughed up for crops or grazed by sheep.