1. World problems
  2. Destructive fish trawling

Destructive fish trawling

Nature

Trawling the sea bottom causes physical damage to the seabed and its wildlife habitats and captures benthic (bottom living) sea creatures that are not used for food.

Incidence

Over 2.5 million hours of bottom trawling took place in Europe’s “protected” areas in 2020.

Fishermen are now using military sonar to hunt and trawl in international waters hundreds of metres below the surface. The long, slow life cycles of the species that live in the deep sea means that their populations will collapse if they are exposed to industrial-scale exploitation. For example, on the orange roughy Hoplostethus atlanticus can reach 150 years old and does not even reproduce until it is in its mid-20s to mid-30s. In the 1980s it was reported that, around seamounts in the waters off New Zealand and Australia, catches of 60 tonnes could be made from a 20 minute trawl. In 2000, there is less than 20% of the Roughy there were 10 or 15 years previously.

The impact of fishing in the deep sea goes far beyond just removing the fish. Fisheries are concentrated into places that have the greatest biological significance; places like seamounts and canyon walls where materials that are wafted in on currents support rich communities of species - corals, sponges, seafans and hydroids. Deep-sea fishing is said to be inflicting terrible collateral damage on these species as trawl meshes plough through the water. Off the east coast of North America bizarre and beautiful fields of glass sponges have been trawled to oblivion. In the Southern Ocean lush forests of invertebrates have been literally stripped from the top of seamounts by trawlers targeting Orange Roughy.

The move to deep-water fishing is being encouraged by governments who are offering subsidies to alleviate the hardship that has been brought on by the collapse of shallow-water fish stocks. Forty percent of the world's trawling grounds are now waters that are deeper than the edge of the continental shelves.

Claim

If current over-fishing continues, trawlers could soon be left chasing jellyfish and even plankton to make "fake" fish products.

Counter-claim

Destructive fish trawling is often exaggerated as a critical issue, but in reality, it pales in comparison to other pressing global challenges. While some ecosystems may be affected, the focus should be on more significant problems like climate change and poverty. Fish populations can rebound, and sustainable practices are evolving. Overemphasizing trawling distracts from urgent issues that require immediate attention and resources, making it a relatively minor concern in the grand scheme of environmental and social priorities.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Broader

Aggravates

Strategy

Metadata

Database
World problems
Type
(G) Very specific problems
Biological classification
N/A
Content quality
Presentable
 Presentable
Language
English
1A4N
J7581
DOCID
12075810
D7NID
164622
Last update
Mar 8, 2024